Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Business

Court gives green light to delayed road project

The Court of Appeal has upheld an Appeal by Landmark Projects (PTY) LTD, Van & Truck Hire PTY LTD to be awarded the tender for Tshesebe-Mosojane-Masunga Road project.

The High Court held that Cul de Sac was entitled to be awarded the tender after the company challenged the processes and factors that influenced award to the two companies.

Other appellants were the Public Procurement and Asset Disposal Board; The Attorney General; Zebra Construction; and Independent Complaints Review Committee (IC).

Landmark, VTH JV bid was P379.3million; Bango/Zebra JV was P391.6million, whilst Cul de Sac was P407.3 million.

At some stage Cul de Sac was disqualified for non- responsiveness on grounds that it had no experience in road construction, but was reinstated at the instance of the Board to which it had complained.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

The evaluation committee recommended Landmark/VTH JV since it was the lowest bidder among responsive bidders.

Initially, the Ministry of Transport and Communications had made a recommendation to the Board for the tender to be awarded in line with the evaluating committee’s report.

The Board did not accept the recommendation, reasoning that the project was under the Government Economic Stimulus Program (ESP) which policy stipulated that projects should not be awarded to any entity which had already benefitted from the program. This factor was initially left out at the Invitation to Tender Stage.

The Board had noted that Landmark/VTH JV had an existing project under the program and therefore was not entitled to another award, but the recommendation was returned for reconsideration.

The ministry then recommended the award to Bango/Zebra JV being the next lowest cost responsive bid to which the Board responded in the affirmative on 12th September 2019.

After the Board had a debriefing session with Landmark/VTH JV and Cul de Sac PTY LTD and the two became aware that ESP Policy consideration played a huge part in the awarding of tender to Bango/Zebra JV.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

The two bidders immediately lodged a complaint to the Board, with Landmark/VTH JV questioning the introduction of ESP factor, whilst Cul de Sac argued two factors; ESP policy and that Bango had already benefitted from ESP.

The second argument was that Landmark/VTH JV had failed to satisfactorily complete their projects on schedule.

However, a Fact-Finding mission was sent to assess the Landmark/VTH JV project in Thalamabele-Mosu road and were satisfied with the performance.

The Board dismissed the complaints by the two companies, but they separately approached the Independent Complaints Review Committee (IC) which convened in December 2019.

“The authenticity of the minutes of that meeting has been stridently challenged by Cul de Sac in court proceedings, arguing that the there was no meeting held to consider its appeal and that those minutes were bogus and contrived,” says the Court of Appeal ruling.

The High Court record shows that that Landmark/VTH JV complaint against introduction of ESP factor was upheld and that Cul de Sac was dismissed.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

It also found that the letter notifying Cul De Sac of its dismissal was unprocedural.

The Court of Appeal set aside the High Court verdict and remitted the matter back to the Independent Commission for the MTC to recommend the award of the tender to Landmark/VTH JV.

The C/A was not satisfied with Cul de Sac experience in road construction and ordered it to pay the costs of the appeal.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

You May Also Like

News

*Yul Moncho demands P250k in damages

News

Jealous man shoots rival, lands lover in hospital A shooting incident at Moletamane Primary school that left a farmer dead and a teacher fighting...

News

• Wildlife demands to see captured live python • Old woman, pastor, charged P5,000 each A Tobane old woman whose yard was haunted by...

Entertainment

Shaya has been following former President Ian Khama’s expenditure and has realised that he never uses his own money. The recent event that comes...

News

Father suspected of poisoning son to avoid child maintenance The estranged father of a toddler who died after eating yoghurt about four months ago...

News

‘I take good care of your daughter and provide for my children. Where will I get a cow to pay you when I am...

Entertainment

Congratulations are in order to Member of Parliament for Selibe Phikwe West, Dithapelo Keorapetse and his wife for a second baby. Shaya spotted the...

News

“I was arrested on the way to the police station,” Kangootui A 37-year-old man of Toteng village was on Friday last week acquitted and...

Entertainment

Online Comedy Show, The Jonny Pula and Triccs show launched its season 2 last week. The show features online comedians and will air 30minutes...

Entertainment

Shaya joined Batswana this week as we followed the LEGABIBO appeal Live on the Voice Newspaper Online Platform. Whilst I listened carefully to the...

News

The organisational restructuring at Water Utilities Corporation (WUC) has cost 450 employees their jobs, it has emerged. Appearing before the Committee on Statutory Bodies...

Entertainment

Famously known for posting funny, blurry pictures and short video skits on his Facebook page, local upcoming comedian Raz Doko, 22, has established a...

Entertainment

In her “Tribute to the world on Covid-19” single Oosi Lemo puts her soul in God’s hands and presents the human race at his...

Entertainment

Batswana ga ba ile batho ba ba matanyola, Akere ba bitswa jalo ,mme legale ha se gore Batswana ba dumalana le matanyola-Advocate Sydney Pilane

News

A mother who trusted her brother to babysit her five-year-old daughter got the shock of her life when she got back to reports of...

Entertainment

Conquering football In football circles, he’s one of the most enterprising and shrewd administrators. From the moment he was elected Chairman of Zebras Supporters...

Advertisement

Copyright © TheVoiceBW. (Since1993) made with ❤️ in Botswana.