Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

NOT AMUSED: Gaolathe


Ndaba lashes out at ‘corrupt’ constitution

The Executive in Botswana has completely usurped Parliament’s mandate through both use of the majority and also through concentrating resources around the work of the Executive, and suffocating resources which could otherwise empower Members of Parliament (MP) to accomplish the mandate vested on them by the Constitution, Alliance for Progressives, Ndaba Gaolathe, says.

When delivering a lecture about the Constitution arrangement in the new Botswana this week, Gaolathe said about there is no clearer demonstration of dictatorship than an Executive that also runs the Legislative process.

He said that in Botswana, the Executive implements law and creates law at the same time. “There cannot be a stronger demonstration of the superfluous idea of separation of powers in Botswana. This arrangement is by definition an authoritarian arrangement.”

Ndaba said that as if this is not enough, the oversight institutions, charged with the responsibility to provide checks and balances, particularly on the Executive, where much of the budget and its implementation rests, are in many ways accountable to the Executive.

“For example, the Auditor-General is appointed, supervised and monitored by the very organ, the Executive, over which she is supposed keep check. This is just one example, and applies to the litany of supposedly oversight institutions such as the DCEC, Ombudsman, NBFIRA, and FIA to name the prominent ones,” he explained.

He added that in more progressive constitutional configurations, these oversight institutions are significantly free from control by the Executive, report directly to Parliament.

“If we allow things to continue this way, we are allowing the flooding rivers to wash away everything from which we derive meaning, we are spectators to Mthakathi playing midfield, defence, and at the same time refereeing the matches in which he is also a player – we are spectators in denial of a dimming hope.”

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

“This is the state of our current Constitutional arrangement. There is famine, an absence of a uniform idea or ideal that we can at present say is common, or known or cherished by all of us.”

The AP President said that “there is that meaning against which we can hold each other accountable, there is no meaning against which we can uniformly hold those in power accountable”.

He noted that in the new Botswana, his party pledges that every citizen will be able to hold any Government, and indeed hold each other accountable if the system is not “giving each citizen a fair chance, a fair flow of opportunities, to become who we aspire to be”.

“The Executive branch of Botswana wields both executive and legislative power, and this is how they do it, in the five days that Parliament meets in a week, the procedures are designed such that four days are reserved only for the Executive to present their business and the legislation drafters are seated at the Attorney General’s chambers and so are part of the Executive and accountable to the Executive, not to Parliament, and certainly not to Members of Parliament”.

Gaolathe also added that in practice, MPs do not have dedicated legislation drafters available to them.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You May Also Like


Police in Molepolole have confirmed the death of a woman who was found hanging from the rafters of a house at Phalane ward on...


Sordid details of sexual assault before her gruesome murder, entered court records last week as new evidence in Barulaganye Aston’s painful last moments, as...


*BHPC reluctant to grant license to China-trained Motswana


Owners of a truck that overturned and spilled cobalt oxide along the A3 road last Wednesday arrived in the country from South Africa last...


WATCH: Defence lawyers in the infamous Turnright Mall armed robbery, scored a point after the presiding magistrate, Goabaone Rammapudi, rejected a request by the...


WATCH: The 10th anniversary celebrations of Kgosi Malope II as paramount Chief of Bangwaketse and his wedding celebrations have been slated for October 5th...


South African trucker pays high price for P20, 000 fine failure A South African trucker has paid a high price for trafficking marijuana into...


In his lifetime, the late former President Robert Mugabe ‘died so many times’ before his real departure to the pearly gates (if indeed he...